5 Favorite Local Bakeries Near Pompton Plains, NJ

May 6th, 2022 by

Pompton Plains, NJ is a charming town filled with a great mix of sweet people and sweet treats. For those days when you’re feeling nostalgic and want a comforting food that reminds you of childhood, be sure to check out some of our favorite local bakeries that are located near Pompton Plains.

5 Favorite Local Bakeries Worth Driving to Near Pompton Plains, NJ

1. Francesca’s Bakery

Francesca’s Bakery believes in the philosophy that local is better and sources most of its ingredients from local farmers. The shop is open Tuesday-Sunday and its baked goods are made from scratch without added preservatives. Some of Francesca’s available baked goods include croissants, tea loaf cakes, buttermilk biscuits, cinnamon buns, and cookies. If you’re looking for more of a meal, consider ordering the shop’s chicken pot pie.

2. Sweet Marie’s Cookie and Coffee House

Sweet Marie’s Cookie and Coffee House opened in 2015 and is a family-owned and operated business. The shop is open on Saturdays and sells a mix of cookie cakes, decorated sugar cookies, traditional cookies, stuffed cookies, and gourmet cookies. Available gourmet cookie flavors include cotton candy, carrot cake, peanut butter brownie, and birthday cake. If you’re in the mood for a traditional cookie, consider ordering the shop’s oatmeal raisin cookie.

3. Lone Star Bakeshop and Bagels

Lone Star Bakeshop and Bagels is a family-owned and operated shop that specializes in kolaches. The shop is open Tuesday-Sunday and sells various breakfast and lunch items as well as sweet kolaches. Available sweet kolach flavors include sweetened cream cheese with streusel, mixed berry with streusel, and Nutella with streusel. If you’re in the mood for something savory, consider trying Lone Star’s cheesesteak with onions and special sauce lunch kolach.

4. The Magpie Bakery

The Magpie Bakery is open Tuesday-Sunday and specializes in sweet and savory pies, coffee, and artisan baked goods. The bakery’s menu includes cakes and cupcakes, bakery items, breakfast pastries, pies, and beverages. Available pie flavors include pulled pork mac and cheese, roasted butternut squash, lemon meringue, peach raspberry, and apple crumb. If you decide to stop by at breakfast, consider trying the shop’s cherry yogurt danish or its apple turnover.

5. Gencarelli’s Bakery

Gencarelli’s Bakery is a family-owned and operated shop that has been open since 1975. The shop is open every day except New Year’s Day and offers a great mix of seasonal and standard baked goods. Its menu includes pound cakes, cheesecakes, pies, cookies, pastries, cupcakes, bread, and more. If you’re looking for a dessert for a birthday party or another special event, Gencarelli’s Bakery even sells cute character cupcakes!
Now that you’ve discovered all these great bakery options, it’s a great time to get in your new 2022 Honda Accord and go get yourself a treat. Stop by Route 23 Honda today and have a look at our selection of new and pre-owned Honda vehicles! We are prepared to help you find your dream Honda vehicle and are happy to answer any questions you may have.

Posted in Uncategorized